Re: [MV] Saving Private Ryan without the SS

Renaud OLGIATI (rolgiati@conexion.com.py)
Tue, 30 Sep 1997 06:28:23 -0500

At 21:34 29/09/99 -0500, you wrote:
>So how good would Saving Private Ryan have been as an historically pretty
>accurate film if there existed no German gear (even repro stuff), no German
>vehicles, nobody knew German tactics or even what the hell their uniforms
>looked like. Re-enactors serve a similar historical purpose, but not in
>Hollywood for cash, they do it of their own hearts and money.

There is enough textual, photographic and film archives extant to make a
mockery of your argument.

>I have friends in France, Germany and other countries in Europe. I try but
>can not imagine the terrors and horrors they have seen. Maybe educating the
>General public about history as accurately as we can is the best way to
>preserve the truth and not let time diminish it into less than what it was.

Re-enactment does not preserve truth about anything, it recreates what the
participants think may be the truth.

It tends to trivialize war, by turning it into a spectator sport (CNN
spings to mind as another guilty party there) so all people see is the
glamour (and high tech side) of it, and conveniently ignore the messy side
of it, the pain, fear and stink of fighting and dying.

Is war a spectacle to be enjoyed ?

Did you folks learn nothing in Vietnam ?

Disgusted, in Darkest Paraguay.

I think... I think it's in my basement...
Let me go upstairs and check.
-- Escher
-- http://personales.conexion.com.py/~rolgiati/ --

===
To unsubscribe from the mil-veh mailing list, send the single word
UNSUBSCRIBE in the body of a message to <mil-veh-request@skylee.com>.